Web Evaluations
The topic that I have chosen is child-care. I would like to focus on tips on how to find quality child-care. The type of evaluation used can be found at
http://www.edsoasis.org/guide3.htmlFirst Search
Attempt |
Search Terms |
Search Engine |
# of hits |
Quality of hits |
1 |
Child-care |
Excite |
Over 30 |
Health issues and quality child-care. |
2 |
Child-care |
Excite |
Over 30 |
Quality child-care. |
The site that I will evaluate first is National Network for Child Care. The URL is
http://www.nncc.org/Choose.Quality.Care/qual.checklist.fcc.htmlThis is the evaluation of National Network for Child Care. I have typed the evaluation format into this document. The original format can be found at the URL address above for the evaluation site.
# |
Criteria |
+ |
_ |
1. |
This site can actually help with schoolwork. It matches what students have to study. |
Yes |
|
2. |
Goals and objectives are clearly stated and are matched to standards |
Yes |
|
3. |
This site helps students think up projects; it helps students work creatively. |
Yes |
|
4. |
This site is useful if you’re by yourself, if you’re working with a few peers, or even as a demo in front of a group of people. |
Yes |
|
5. |
You can tell who created the site, and you can learn about the person and his or her professional credentials. |
Yes |
|
6. |
The information on this site is more extensive or more current than what you’re likely to find at school. |
Yes |
|
7. |
You can use the site of get a message to subject-area experts, to the author of the site, or to exchange data and ideas to other students. |
Yes |
|
8. |
Someone screens messages before they appear on the site. |
Yes |
|
9. |
If the site is intended to help students with a school project, there’s a place where students can share their work OR suggestions for ways to share projects locally. |
Yes |
|
10. |
You can link from this site out to carefully selected and well-described sites on the same topic. |
Yes |
|
11. |
The site uses visual aids such as charts, maps, graphs and images effectively, and may include templates of forms to help with student work. |
Yes |
|
12. |
The site has great colors. You can read all the words, and the graphics look like they belong. |
No |
|
13. |
You can find your way around with no problem. |
Yes |
|
14. |
If the site uses "new" tech goodies, like shockwave, sound, java and animation, they are used to make the information more visual. |
No |
|
15. |
The site respects the user and any people it refers to. |
Yes |
Second Search
Attempt |
Search Terms |
Search Engine |
# of hits |
Quality hits |
1. |
Childcare |
Yahoo |
74 |
0 |
2. |
How to find quality childcare |
Yahoo |
372 |
0 |
3. |
Quality child-care |
Yahoo |
18 |
1 |
I choose the site http://www.daycaretrust.org.UK/choosingframes.cfm
# |
Criteria |
+ |
_ |
1. |
This site can actually help with schoolwork. It matches what students have to study. |
Yes |
|
2. |
Goals and objectives are clearly stated and are matched to standards |
Yes |
|
3. |
This site helps students think up projects; it helps students work creatively. |
Yes |
|
4. |
This site is useful if you’re by yourself, if you’re working with a few peers, or even as a demo in front of a group of people. |
Yes |
|
5. |
You can tell who created the site, and you can learn about the person and his or her professional credentials. |
Yes |
|
6. |
The information on this site is more extensive or more current than what you’re likely to find at school. |
Yes |
|
7. |
You can use the site of get a message to subject-area experts, to the author of the site, or to exchange data and ideas to other students. |
Yes |
|
8. |
Someone screens messages before they appear on the site. |
Yes |
|
9. |
If the site is intended to help students with a school project, there’s a place where students can share their work OR suggestions for ways to share projects locally. |
No |
|
10. |
You can link from this site out to carefully selected and well-described sites on the same topic. |
Yes |
|
11. |
The site uses visual aids such as charts, maps, graphs and images effectively, and may include templates of forms to help with student work. |
Yes |
|
12. |
The site has great colors. You can read all the words, and the graphics look like they belong. |
Yes |
|
13. |
You can find your way around with no problem. |
Yes |
|
14. |
If the site uses "new" tech goodies, like shockwave, sound, java and animation, they are used to make the information more visual. |
No |
|
15. |
The site respects the user and any people it refers to. |
Yes |
Third Search
Attempt |
Search Terms |
Search Engine |
# of hits |
Quality hits |
1. |
Quality child-care |
Northern Light |
18 |
1 |
2. |
Child-care |
Northern Light |
454,635 |
1 |
3. |
I chose the site http://www.naccrra.net/childcareaware for my last search evaluation.
# |
Criteria |
+ |
_ |
1. |
This site can actually help with schoolwork. It matches what students have to study. |
Yes |
|
2. |
Goals and objectives are clearly stated and are matched to standards |
Yes |
|
3. |
This site helps students think up projects; it helps students work creatively. |
No |
|
4. |
This site is useful if you’re by yourself, if you’re working with a few peers, or even as a demo in front of a group of people. |
Yes |
|
5. |
You can tell who created the site, and you can learn about the person and his or her professional credentials. |
Yes |
|
6. |
The information on this site is more extensive or more current than what you’re likely to find at school. |
Yes |
|
7. |
You can use the site of get a message to subject-area experts, to the author of the site, or to exchange data and ideas to other students. |
Yes |
|
8. |
Someone screens messages before they appear on the site. |
Yes |
|
9. |
If the site is intended to help students with a school project, there’s a place where students can share their work OR suggestions for ways to share projects locally. |
No |
|
10. |
You can link from this site out to carefully selected and well-described sites on the same topic. |
Yes |
|
11. |
The site uses visual aids such as charts, maps, graphs and images effectively, and may include templates of forms to help with student work. |
Yes |
|
12. |
The site has great colors. You can read all the words, and the graphics look like they belong. |
Yes |
|
13. |
You can find your way around with no problem. |
Yes |
|
14. |
If the site uses "new" tech goodies, like shockwave, sound, java and animation, they are used to make the information more visual. |
No |
|
15. |
The site respects the user and any people it refers to. |
Yes |